Why is there such a big disparity in sales performance? After all:
Many recruiting ads list "knockout factors" such as minimum levels of education and experience. The purpose of these knockout factors is to screen out undesirable candidates. The question is, is there really a correlation between the chosen knockout factors and an individual's ability to sell?
When my clients’ recruiting ads include education and/or experience as knockout factors, I like to have a little fun with them. I say something like:
(Name), imagine that I have two candidates for your sales job opening. One has both the college degree and the five years of sales experience that are listed as “minimum requirements” in your recruiting ad. The other candidate doesn’t have a college degree, and she only has two years of sales experience. But, she has relationships with dozens of C-level executives that would be good prospects for your company’s products and services. She could easily book fifteen appointments during her first week on the job. Which candidate would you like to speak with first?
Which candidate would you like to speak with first? If you are like my clients, it’s the woman with the relationships. Unfortunately, now I have to deliver the bad news:
Unfortunately you will never see this candidate because she is being screened out by your company’s knockout factors!
It is easy to rationalize why education might appear to be a reliable knockout factor. The thought process usually goes something like this:
“We sell a very technical offering. You really need to be an engineer in order to understand it. So, we should focus our recruiting efforts on individuals with engineering degrees.”
“Our product line is constantly changing, and we have a rapid rate of new product introductions. Our salespeople need to be pretty sharp to keep up with all of the new product information. So, we should only hire people with college degrees, as these people have proven they know how to learn.”
These lines of thinking seem logical. But, are people with engineering degrees really the only people that can understand detailed technical information? And, how does someone’s ability to acquire a college degree indicate whether they learn quickly or slowly?
Another common mistake is focusing recruiting efforts on candidates that meet certain minimum requirements for either amount or type of sales experience. This practice is usually based on expectations that past sales experience will produce future sales results, and that experienced candidates will not require a lot of (sales skills or product knowledge) training. This should enable them to become productive more quickly, which is why many companies are willing to pay a premium for experienced sales job candidates.
Unfortunately, there is compelling evidence that hiring experienced sales candidates simply recycles mediocrity. In their book, How to Hire and Develop Your Next Top Performer, Herb Greenberg, Harold Weinstein and Patrick Sweeney compared results from hundreds of thousands of assessments that were conducted over several decades with actual sales performance measurements and concluded:
Based upon these statistics, the practice of hiring experienced sales candidates will produce an unsatisfactory result as much as 80 percent of the time!
A much better indicator of future success is whether your company’s sales job candidates have the talents required for success in your company’s specific sales job. Candidates that have the talents required for success and significant experience selling similar products or services are truly ideal candidates!
If you have to choose between an experienced candidate that lacks key talents required for sales success and an inexperienced candidate that has all of the talents required for sales success, which candidate should you choose? The inexperienced candidate! Why? Because a lack of experience can be overcome with training. A lack of the talents required for sales success cannot!
Resumes are purely subjective documents. They are written with the specific intention of describing an individual's skills and experiences in the most favorable possible light, for the purpose of convincing you to invite the individual to take the next step in your company's recruiting process.
Do some people misrepresent their qualifications on their resumes? Absolutely! However, even when the information on a resume is completely accurate, how accurately does it predict that individual's ability to sell your company's specific products and services?
What happens during an interview? Interviewees attempt to answer questions in a manner that makes the best impression. Meanwhile, interviewers form personal opinions about the interviewees' qualifications. What's the result? Far too often it is hiring mistakes!
What do recruiting ads, resumes and interviews have in common? They all describe tools and processes that rely completely on SUBJECTIVE information.
I don't mean to suggest that subjective information is useless. Subjective information is a valid and valuable component of any "people decision". But, if your company is struggling with 80/20 sales team performance, clearly your recruiting process isn't working as well as you would like. Something needs to change.
If you want to improve the overall quality of your sales job candidate pool, shift your focus away from education and experience and toward performance-based measures.
Look at it this way – what would a new salesperson have to do to cause you to say, “Man, that (salesperson’s name) is doing a GREAT job!” How you will measure a new salesperson’s performance during their first thirty, sixty, ninety days on the job?
What activities will you expect them to perform?
What results will you expect these activities to produce, and in what time frame?
Identify what you expect your new salespeople to achieve, and candidly share this information with your job candidates during every step of the recruiting process, beginning with your recruiting ad!Here is a 5-step performance-based recruiting process that will help you consistently hire top sales performers:
1. Write a Performance-Based Recruiting Ad: Before you write your recruiting ad, carefully consider the following questions and suggestions:
2. Scrutinize Resumes for Accomplishments: Successful salespeople know that results sell. When these salespeople prospect, they talk to prospects about the results their companies have produced. When these salespeople write resumes, they write about the results they have produced and other accomplishments (awards, recognition, etc.), not just the duties they have performed.
3. Conduct Telephone Screening Calls: If a job candidate interests you, schedule a 20 to 30 minute telephone screening call. Focus this conversation on the performance criteria that are most critical for success in your sales position. This will enable you to determine relatively quickly whether the candidate warrants a full (in-person or telephone) interview.
4. Assess Qualified Candidates: For candidates that pass the telephone screen, the next step to gather OBJECTIVE information about their sales talents with specialized sales assessment tests.When I say “specialized sales assessment tests,” I am NOT referring to personality or behavioral tests like Myers-Briggs or DISC. These types of "communication style" assessments are useful for personal development. However, they are not effective for predicting whether or not an individual will succeed in sales.
An individual can have every talent required to achieve top sales performance. However, if they don't ENJOY the activities involved in selling, it is unlikely they will perform very well for very long.
Does this scenario sound familiar? You hire a salesperson that looks and sounds great. They seem to have all of the talent in the world. They hit the ground running and generate impressive results during their first few months on the job. However, over time their performance starts to decline, and no one can figure out why. Far too often the reason is they don't LIKE selling!
5. Conduct In-Person Interviews: Now you are prepared to conduct a thorough, performance-based interview. After all, look at the quality of the information you have collected! For each candidate you are planning to interview, you should have in your hands:
That's perfectly understandable. It's also why we offer a variety of sales recruiting services. It's completely up to you how many (or how few) of these services you consume. Our goal is to match the services we provide to your own specific needs and budget.
If you ask performance-based questions and clearly outline your expectations for new hire sales performance, you should have more productive communications with your job candidates. You can even include specific performance expectations in your offer letters!
If you would like to take advantage of our no-obligation demonstration, please contact us. We will respond within 24 hours.